New Buffalo, Michigan, a charming lakeside town nestled along the shores of Lake Michigan, offers more than just stunning sunsets and sandy beaches. It’s a haven for food lovers, boasting a vibrant culinary scene that caters to every palate and preference. From casual beachfront bites to sophisticated fine dining experiences, New Buffalo provides a diverse array of restaurants and culinary delights waiting to be discovered. Whether you’re seeking a quick and tasty lunch, a romantic dinner, or a family-friendly feast, this article will guide you through the must-try foods and restaurants that showcase the best of New Buffalo’s gastronomic landscape. Get ready to embark on a delicious adventure!
Casual Eats and Beachfront Bites
When the sun is shining and the lake is calling, sometimes all you need is a relaxed meal with a view. New Buffalo has plenty of options for casual dining that perfectly complement a day at the beach or exploring the town.
The Stray Dog Bar & Grill: A Local Favorite
The Stray Dog Bar & Grill is an institution in New Buffalo. This popular spot is known for its laid-back atmosphere, friendly service, and delicious American fare. Its a great place to kick back and relax with the whole family. Of all the food in New Buffalo MI, you will not regret giving this place a try. Their signature dish, the Stray Dog Burger, is a must-try – a juicy patty piled high with toppings, served with crispy fries. Located just steps from the beach, The Stray Dog offers stunning views of Lake Michigan, making it the perfect place to enjoy a casual lunch or dinner while soaking up the sun. With its dog-friendly patio, you can even bring your furry friend along for the fun! The price range is moderate, making it an accessible option for families and budget-conscious travelers.
Skip’s Other Place: Pizza Perfection
For pizza lovers, Skip’s Other Place is a must-visit. This family-owned pizzeria serves up delicious, New York-style pies with a variety of toppings to choose from. Whether you prefer a classic pepperoni pizza or something more adventurous, Skip’s has something for everyone. Their thin-crust pizza is perfectly crispy, and the sauce is bursting with flavor. In addition to pizza, Skip’s also offers a selection of sandwiches, salads, and appetizers. With its casual atmosphere and friendly service, Skip’s Other Place is the perfect spot for a quick and easy meal with family and friends. They even have outdoor seating, allowing you to enjoy the beautiful New Buffalo weather while you dine.
Redamak’s: A Burger Institution
No trip to New Buffalo is complete without a visit to Redamak’s, home of the famous Butter Burger. This no-frills establishment has been serving up delicious burgers and fries since way back when. Their burgers are simple but perfect, featuring a juicy patty, melted butter, and your choice of toppings. The atmosphere is casual and unpretentious, making it a great place to grab a quick and satisfying meal. Be prepared to wait in line, as Redamak’s is a popular spot, but trust us, it’s worth it. The Butter Burger is a New Buffalo institution, and it’s a must-try for any visitor. With its affordable prices and classic American fare, Redamak’s is a timeless favorite.
Upscale Dining and Special Occasions
When you’re looking for a more refined dining experience, New Buffalo offers a selection of upscale restaurants that are perfect for special occasions or romantic evenings.
The Terrace Room: Elegant Lakeside Dining
Located in the Harbor Grand Hotel, The Terrace Room offers an elegant dining experience with stunning views of New Buffalo Harbor. The restaurant’s menu features contemporary American cuisine with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients. Their dishes are beautifully presented, and the flavors are complex and satisfying. The Terrace Room is the perfect place to celebrate a special occasion or enjoy a romantic dinner. The service is impeccable, and the atmosphere is sophisticated and refined. While the price range is higher than some of the more casual options in town, the experience is well worth it.
Brewster’s Italian Cafe: Fine Italian Cuisine
If you’re craving authentic Italian cuisine, look no further than Brewster’s Italian Cafe. This charming restaurant serves up classic Italian dishes with a modern twist. Their pasta is homemade, and their sauces are bursting with flavor. Be sure to start with their Caprese salad! Brewster’s also offers a selection of Italian wines to complement your meal. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it the perfect place to enjoy a relaxed and romantic dinner. The price range is moderate to high, but the quality of the food and service makes it well worth the investment.
Local Specialties and Hidden Gems
Beyond the well-known restaurants, New Buffalo is also home to a few hidden gems that are worth seeking out. These establishments offer unique flavors and experiences that you won’t find anywhere else. Food in New Buffalo MI is more than just restaurants it is an experience!
Custom House: Seafood Sensations
Custom House is a hidden gem known for its fresh seafood and creative dishes. This restaurant prides itself on using locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Their menu changes seasonally to reflect the freshest catches of the day. Custom House offers a unique dining experience that is both delicious and sustainable. Their atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it the perfect place to enjoy a romantic dinner or a special occasion. Be sure to ask about their daily specials, as they often feature unique and innovative dishes.
David’s Deli: A Sandwich Staple
David’s Deli is a long standing New Buffalo staple, offering a wide array of sandwiches, salads, and soups. This is a great place to grab a delicious lunch or pick up sandwiches for a picnic at the beach. David’s Deli is known for its generous portions and affordable prices. Their atmosphere is casual and friendly, making it the perfect place to grab a quick and easy meal. If you are looking for a more local experience, look no further than this family run shop! They even have outdoor seating, allowing you to enjoy the beautiful New Buffalo weather while you dine.
Sweet Treats and Dessert Destinations
No culinary journey is complete without indulging in some sweet treats. New Buffalo has several options for satisfying your sweet tooth.
Oink’s Dutch Treat: Ice Cream Extravaganza
Oink’s Dutch Treat is a New Buffalo institution, known for its enormous portions of ice cream and its whimsical atmosphere. This ice cream parlor offers a wide variety of flavors, from classic vanilla to more adventurous options. Oink’s is the perfect place to cool off on a hot day and indulge in a sweet treat. Be prepared to wait in line, as Oink’s is a popular spot, but trust us, it’s worth it. Their ice cream is creamy and delicious, and the portions are generous enough to share. With its fun atmosphere and delicious ice cream, Oink’s Dutch Treat is a must-visit for any visitor to New Buffalo.
Froelich’s Kitchen and Pantry: Baked Goods and More
Froelich’s Kitchen and Pantry is more than just a bakery; it’s a culinary destination. This charming shop offers a wide variety of baked goods, including cakes, pies, cookies, and pastries. Froelich’s also offers a selection of gourmet sandwiches, salads, and soups. Their ingredients are fresh and the items are always delicious! Whether you’re looking for a sweet treat or a savory snack, Froelich’s has something to satisfy your cravings.
Conclusion
From casual beachfront bites to sophisticated fine dining experiences, New Buffalo offers a culinary adventure for every taste and budget. Whether you’re craving a juicy burger, a fresh seafood dish, or a decadent dessert, you’ll find it in this charming lakeside town. So, come explore the diverse restaurants and hidden gems of New Buffalo and discover your own favorite culinary delights. With its beautiful setting and vibrant food scene, New Buffalo offers a truly memorable dining experience. Bon appétit!
